Politics without Vision
Thinking without a Banister in the Twentieth Century
From Plato through the nineteenth century, the West could draw on comprehensive political visions to guide government and society. Now, for the first time in more than two thousand years, Tracy B. Strong contends, we have lost our foundational supports. In the words of Hannah Arendt, the state of political thought in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries has left us effectively "thinking without a banister".
"Politics without Vision" takes up the thought of seven influential thinkers, each of whom attempted to construct a political solution to this problem: Nietzsche, Weber, Freud, Lenin, Schmitt, Heidegger, and Arendt. None of these theorists were liberals nor, excepting possibly Arendt, were they democrats – and some might even be said to have served as handmaidens to totalitarianism. And all to a greater or lesser extent shared the common conviction that the institutions and practices of liberalism are inadequate to the demands and stresses of the present times. In examining their thought, Strong acknowledges the political evil that some of their ideas served to foster but argues that these were not necessarily the only paths their explorations could have taken. By uncovering the turning points in their thought – and the paths not taken – Strong strives to develop a political theory that can avoid, and perhaps help explain, the mistakes of the past while furthering the democratic impulse.
Confronting the widespread belief that political thought is on the decline, Strong puts forth a brilliant and provocative counterargument that in fact it has endured – without the benefit of outside support. A compelling rendering of contemporary political theory, "Politics without Vision" is sure to provoke discussion among scholars in many fields.
About the Author
Tracy B. Strong is distinguished professor in the Department of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego. He is a former editor of "Political Theory" and the author or editor of many books, including "Friedrich Nietzsche and the Politics of Transfiguration", "Jean-Jacques Rousseau and the Politics of the Ordinary", and "The Many and the One: Religious and Secular Perspectives on Ethical Pluralism in the Modern World".
Reviews
"An outstanding study of twentieth-century political thought, conceptually challenging but accessibly written. Strong's unmistakable voice is at once lyrical and sober, and 'Politics without Vision' is erudite and illuminating at every turn" – Patchen Markell, University of Chicago
"This is an important book that has needed to be written, that Tracy Strong is perhaps uniquely positioned to write, and that some of us have been waiting for him to write for a long time. He does so expertly and knowledgeably with an astonishing grasp of a rich variety of texts" – Joshua Foa Dienstag, University of California, Los Angeles
"What does it mean to 'think without a banister,' without the support of the certitudes previously supplied by religion, science, and the philosophy of history? In 'Politics without Vision', Tracy B. Strong provides a remarkable and searching survey of the responses given by seven twentieth-century thinkers as they struggled to articulate the relation between morality and politics in a post-Christian, post-Enlightenment, and post-historicist world. The results are both surprising and bracing, moving judgment, decision, and action into the space previously occupied by falsely systemic accounts of the relation between theory and practice" – Dana Villa, University of Notre Dame
"A marvelous tour de force brimming with intellectual excitement. With extraordinarily impressive scholarship, Tracy B. Strong carefully constructs the historical context of each of the thinkers he engages, while simultaneously keeping a laser-like focus on the urgent goal of accumulating pieces to the puzzle as to what sense we might be able to give to 'the political' in a world where we must think, as Arendt said, 'without banisters'. A book not to be missed" – Stephen K. White, University of Virginia
