After the Beautiful
Hegel and the Philosophy of Pictorial Modernism
In his Berlin lectures on fine art, Hegel argued that art involves a unique form of aesthetic intelligibility – the expression of a distinct collective self-understanding that develops through historical time. Hegel's approach to art has been influential in a number of different contexts, but in a twist of historical irony Hegel would die just before the most radical artistic revolution in history: modernism. In "After the Beautiful", Robert B. Pippin, looking at modernist paintings by artists such as Edouard Manet and Paul Cezanne through Hegel's lens, does what Hegel never had the chance to do.
While Hegel could never engage modernist painting, he did have an understanding of modernity, and in it, art – he famously asserted – was "a thing of the past", no longer an important vehicle of self-understanding and no longer an indispensable expression of human meaning. Pippin offers a sophisticated exploration of Hegel's position and its implications. He also shows that had Hegel known how the social institutions of his day would ultimately fail to achieve his own version of genuine equality, a mutuality of recognition, he would have had to explore a different, new role for art in modernity. After laying this groundwork, Pippin goes on to illuminate the dimensions of Hegel's aesthetic approach in the path-breaking works of Manet, the "grandfather of modernism", drawing on art historians T. J. Clark and Michael Fried to do so. He concludes with a look at Cezanne, the "father of modernism", this time as his works illuminate the relationship between Hegel and the philosopher who would challenge Hegel's account of both modernity and art – Martin Heidegger.
Elegantly inter-weaving philosophy and art history, "After the Beautiful" is a stunning reassessment of the modernist project. It gets at the core of the significance of modernism itself and what it means in general for art to have a history. Ultimately, it is a testament, via Hegel, to the distinctive philosophical achievements of modernist art in the unsettled, tumultuous era we have inherited.
Contents:
Acknowledgments
1. Introduction
2. Philosophy and Painting: Hegel and Manet
3. Politics and Ontology: Clark and Fried
4. Art and Truth: Heidegger and Hegel
5. Concluding Remarks
Bibliography
Index
About the Author
Robert B. Pippin is the Evelyn Stefansson Nef Distinguished Service Professor in the John U. Nef Committee on Social Thought, the Department of Philosophy, and the College at the University of Chicago. He is the author of several books, including "Nietzsche, Psychology, and First Philosophy", also published by the University of Chicago Press, and, most recently, "Fatalism in American Film Noir: Some Cinematic Philosophy".
Reviews
"There is a fair amount of philosophical literature about whether Hegel could accommodate modern, post-1840s art within his philosophy, but that field usually divides into the 'Yes, he can', and 'No, he cannot' camps. Both camps generally argue on the basis of canonical Hegelian texts, differing only on the implications they draw from those texts. In 'After the Beautiful', however, the historical Hegel himself is drawn into criticism under Robert B. Pippin's contemporary interpretation – called to alter his original account in certain key areas if he is to stay true to his original program. This is a very ambitious way of doing philosophy, and Pippin pulls it off very well" – Terry Pinkard, Georgetown University
"'After the Beautiful' is a strikingly original contribution to the debate on the relevance of Hegel's 'Aesthetics' to the contemporary world, and not just the art world. Taking a modified Hegelian approach shorn of metaphysical commitments, the author seeks to shed light on the 'crisis' of modernism: how art might perhaps make sense – both intelligible and felt sense – of a senseless, disjointed reality. Through subtle readings of texts and artworks, Robert B. Pippin brings out the need to interpret art as a mode of address, as communication in a society that puts communicability in question. This is a challenging book, which brings Hegel to life in unexpected ways" – Martin Donougho, University of South Carolina
"From the first contemporary commentaries on Edouard Manet to the most sophisticated art historical interpretations, the critical response to modernist painting has always suffered from a mismatch between aesthetic and social accounts of its nature. Robert B. Pippin's new book offers nothing less than a compelling argument overcoming this dualism. His philosophical reconstruction of the history of art from Manet to Cezanne demonstrates forcefully that in modernist painting the most unsettling question of modern life found expression: whether a meaningful social practice is conceivable" – Ralph Ubl, University of Basel
